In a time not too different from now, those who promoted Capitalism and technology (CTs) were in a political struggle for control with those who were socialists and environmentalist (SEs). It really wasn't going well for either side. There were accusations and claims by both sides. When the element of the professional politician and super-rich was introduced, it started getting difficult to tell the truth of any statement. Both the Socialists and the Capitalists were being played for the benefit of the One-Percent.
In a move of sheer desperation, one of the sides; it doesn't matter which; proposed that the Capitalist-Technologists just take the cities and leave the Socialist-Environmentalists to survive out in the surrounding country. The CTs would get all of the technology, industry and wealth of the cities. The SEs could have social programs to their hearts content and all be John Muir wannabes living outside of "civilization" and in the wilderness.
Well, the idea caught on. Both sides were happy and The Agreement was formalized. The CTs would get the pesky SEs out of their politics and the SEs wouldn't have to worry about CTs constantly trying to destroy nature. It seemed like a win-win deal.
Sometime later two friends, one a CT and the other an SE, met when the CT was found wandering through the woods not far from the city.
"What are you doing out here?" the SE friend inquired.
"Oh," replied the CT, "I just came out to see how you're doing."
The two men sat down by a babbling brook under the shade of a large cottonwood tree. The sun was shining and the air was cool and clear. The SE noticed that his CT friend was looking around with a sad expression on his face, but he said nothing.
"I'm glad you came to see me," said the SE, opening his back pack and pulling out a small package along with a jug of water. CT smiled as SE unwrapped the package, laying pieces of meat and some sort of root vegetable on a rock.
"I hope you'll join me," SE smiled. "It isn't a four-star restaurant, but it is healthy and tasty.
"Thank you," CT accepted a piece of the meat. SE noticed how his friend devoured the meat as though he hadn't eaten in weeks, but he said nothing.
"So, how's life in the city?" SE asked.
"Oh, fine," said CT. "It must be tough out here. You doing okay?"
"We're doing great," said the SE with enthusiasm. "We're already seeing recovery in many areas. We found that we do best as hunter-gatherers so we had to relearn hunter-gatherer skills. We really weren't prepared for that. It was rather difficult for a while, but the hunter-gatherer life-style lends itself well to a socialist community structure."
"We are being very careful with electricity. We don't have any problem generating the power; there's solar and wind a plenty; but we know that some day our solar panels, wind generators and batteries are going to wear out. We're hoping they will last until we can find a solution. Cooking and heating are another problem. If we keep our population in check, we shouldn't have to worry about pollution, but much of our land has not recovered from the deforestation and other ravages of previous humans. We must figure out how we are going to cook and heat without putting more stress on the environment. We're doing a lot of experimentation with solar and thermal cooking, and we're exploring other alternatives."
"Then," concluded the CT, "life is pretty tough."
"Oh, no!" exclaimed the SE. "Not at all. We have plenty of time to explore and work on these issues. Each of us hunts or gathers until the larders are full. A few do a bit of farming. Working together it doesn't take long to have plenty for everyone. Usually we only have to go hunting once or twice as week. Besides, being omnivores, like the bears, there is still lots to eat even if we don't get a lot of meat."
"So food isn't scarce?" CT looked down at the piece of meat he was enjoying.
"To the contrary," SE replied, "if we had any more we'd all have to start going on diets." The two men laughed. SE didn't miss that CT's laugh was rather forced.
"How do you hunt? Aren't you out of ammunition?"
"Just about," admitted SE. "We have to be really careful with ammunition and most of our guns are already useless."
"Then what do you do?"
"In our small group we have a fellow who has learned to make a really fine bows and is teaching others how to use it. In fact, he and some other bow-makers have gone from tribe to tribe teaching the skill." SE paused and handed his friend a piece of meat. "This dried meat comes from an Elk I saw him bring down with one shot. That's been weeks ago, and we're still eating off it."
"Wow," is all CT could say. Being his third piece, he did take a bit more time eating.
"We have people in our tribe who already knew about dressing, drying, tanning hides, and making use of every part of the kill. Personally, I hate killing other animals for food, but we don't kill them for fun and nothing goes to waste."
"What about housing," CT asked. "Where are you living?"
"A few of us live apart from the common areas, but most of us live in small groups of fifteen to twenty close enough that we can share." SE had to frown. "Unfortunately, many brought campers and RVs when we left the cities. Now we have to figure out what to do with them if we decide that we need to move on."
"Really?" CT seemed almost relieved that they had a problem.
"Yes, we didn't think about not having vehicles. We're working on incorporating our RVs into their surroundings so that they don't have a negative impact if we must abandon them. Historically some hunter-gatherers in history stayed in areas for several generations. We're hoping that we'll have enough time to figure it out."
"Don't you miss your truck?"
"Naw. We never need to go that far. Even when we trade with another group we all walk to a place between us and do our trading. Sometimes we'll have ponies to carry the goods."
"Sounds rather ideal," CT could not help but to admire his friend's new life.
"Well, we don't have all of the conveniences and comforts that you have in the city," SE said, "but we elected to give them up. Medical care was almost an immediate issue. We put a lot of emphasis on preventative care and there is a lot of good medicine out here - after all, most of your drugs started out as a plant extract - but we know that we're not going to live as long. There isn't any bypass surgery out here and a lot of things are going to kill us that don't concern you. We've had a number of people die who would have survive with your technology, but everyone I know accepted that reality before they came."
"So you'd still rather be out here?" CT asked.
"Absolutely! It's a good life!" SE was beaming. "How are things for you?"
"I have to be honest," CT hung his head. "I didn't come out here to see how you were doing. I ran away from the city."
"Really?"
"Yes," CT continued. "we can't survive much longer."
"Why's that?" Actually SE knew the answer. He had tried to tell his CT friends for years, but no one listened.
"Food and water have become currency. If there is a square centimeter of soil, someone is trying to grow something to eat and having to stand guard or it will be stolen. Pets and zoo animals were eaten a long time ago, and now there is even cannibalism. I can't tell you the last time I tasted meat. City people didn't think about the fact that food doesn't originate in a supermarket."
"Clean water is non-existent and air pollution is appalling. People are living in cars that were abandoned in the middle of the street because there isn't any fuel. We probably haven't done a life-saving surgery since the day the Agreement went into effect, and people are dying by the hundreds - mostly of starvation, violence over food and water and then from disease."
CT looked at his friend with tears in his eyes. "For years you told us about our interdependence with all of nature. Even if we didn't want to live in the wilderness, you wanted us to respect and protect the country and the wilderness because it was our source of life. But we didn't believe you. We had been thoroughly convinced, by the One Percent, that technology could do everything. We were wrong. DEAD wrong! We can't make water. We can't make air. We can't produce food. Technology can't do or make anything without the nature around it."
"I'm truly sorry," said SE, putting a comforting hand on his friend's shoulder. "I wanted you to learn. Not die."
"We have doomed ourselves," said CT. "Soon after all of you left, we built a high wall around the city so that you couldn't come back."
"You built a wall to keep us out?"
"Yes. Isn't it ironic? We built it because we didn't want you trying to sneak back into the land of opportunity." CT gave a sardonic laugh. "We didn't want you to come groveling back to enjoy the fruits of our labor. The wall that was to protect us and our way of life is now our prison wall. People are climbing the wall at night to escape."
"The government doesn't want us leaving. They keep telling us that everything is fine, that you SEs are practically extinct already, and that they have a technological solution that will soon be unveiled." CT paused. "We know they're lying. We're dead."
"I feel like such a coward," CT continued after a short pause. "I went over the wall last night. I drank water from a stream! The purest most wonderful water I've tasted since the Agreement. I thought I was going to freeze to death during the night, but I somehow felt free. This morning I found these berries." He reached into his pocket and came out with some white waxy looking berries. "They made me sick as hell, but at least I ate."
"Those are Snow berries," SE tried not to laugh at his distraught friend. "Even the bears don't eat them. In fact, I don't know that any animal eats them."
"How about that?" CT almost smiled. "My first free meal and I chose a non-edible."
"Are all the cities as bad?"
"I think other cities are just as bad, maybe worse. We don't really know because transportation and communications have been gone for a long time."
SE gave his poor CT friend the rest of the food in his bag. There was nothing he could say. For years the Capitalist-Technology majority had berated he and his friends. They had controlled government and refused to protect the sources of life. Now they were dying from their own greed, delusions and myopia.
"You can come with me," SE finally said. "Our tribe can handle one more, but I don't know what you're going to do about the cities." SE felt ashamed for this thoughts. He knew that, if they were to open the gates of the cities, the people would come pouring out like starving locust and things would be as bad or worse than before. He thought that, as inhumane as it might be, they needed to keep the wall to protect life on Earth from the cities. The cities were filled with death.
"If only we had listened when you warned us," CT said as the two walked into the forest together. As the woods began to engulf them CT took a moment to glance back toward the city. "If only we had listened."